Blog Categories/Tags
1/2 & 1/2
120
17.4 Cochineal
36
3rd Party Certification
60
Albert King
Ansel Adams
Antibiotics
Antoine de Saint-Exupéry
Art
Art Criticism
Art Knowledge News
Audible
baa
Barthes
Basic Lamb Recipes
Baudelaire
Beauty
Big Food
Big Yarn
Biking
Bill of Rights
Bittman
Blanket
Bolano
Botticelli
Botton
Breeding
Breeding Stock
Buddha
Bullamalita
Cage
Capitalism
carnivores
Catskill Merino Hat
Cesare Pavese
Cezanne
Chunky Yarn
CIA
Cicero
Clara Parkes
Cleanth Brooks
Cochineal
Colette
Colorant
Constable
Cooking Lamb
Corn
Corriedale
Coup de Grace
Cous Cous
Coyotes
Criticism
David Foster Wallace
DaVinci
Delanceyplace
Deworming
Discount Code
Dogs
Dominion?
doxa
Drugs
Duck
Ducks
Dye
Eartag 36
Eating Policy
Electric Fence
Elkins
Employment
End of Poverty
Ewe 159
Ewes
Exercise
Experimental Dyeing
Facebook
Factory Farm
FAMACHA
Famous Knitters
Farm Help
Farm Stand
Farming
FDR
Fecals
Festival
Fish
Flaubert
Florence Fabricant
Fluxus
Food
Food Deserts
Food Flock
Food Politics
Food Swamps
Foodie
Frances Middendorf
Francesco Mastalia
Garlic
Garlic Cultivation
Georgia O'Keeffe
Gertrude Stein
Gift Certificates
Gilbert-Rolfe
Goncourt Brothers
Goodreads
Gordon Lightfoot
Grazing
Grazing 2009
Great Expectations
Green Mountain Spinnery
Green turn
Greener Shades
Greenmarket
Greenmarket; Union Square
Hahn
Hand Dyeing
Hand Dyeing Workshop
Hang Tag
Hang Tags
Hannah
Hats
Hats for Haiti
Headcheese
Heather
Heather Yarn
Heatwave
Heine
Hemingway
Herbicide
Hickey
Improv
Indigo
Ink
Intelligence
Interns
Irene
Irony
Jack
James Joyce
James Woods
Jane Austen
Jimi Hendrix
Johnny Cash
Judy Geib
Kafka
Kim
Knitter's Review
Knitter's Slideshow
Knitting
Knitting Gauge
Krauss
La Gioconda
Lamb
Lamb 072
Lamb 427
Lamb Andouille Sausage
Lamb Bacon
Lamb Cuisine
Lamb Gallery
Lamb Jerky
Lamb Pastrami
Lamb Recipes
Lamb Sausage
Lamb Sausages
Lamb Stew
Lamb Stones
Lambing
Lambing 2009
Lambing 2010
Lambing 2011
Lambs
Lamb's Quarters
Latin
Lede
Leg of Lamb
Limited Edition
Limited Edition Color
Limited Edition Heather
Little Phrase
Madder
Maiwa
Manure
Marcel Proust
Market
Martha and the Vandellas
Max
Media
Merguez
Merryville
Metaphor
Michael Pollan
Micron
Mittens
Montaigne
Morning
Movies
Mrs. Dalloway
Munch
Muses
Blog Entries by Date
<< Back to main

A State of Thralldom

Posted 2/7/2011 8:40am by Eugene Wyatt.

My morning reading:

A work of art encountered as a work of art is an experience, not a statement or an answer to a question. Art is not only about something; it is some­thing. A work of art is a thing in the world, not just a text or com­mentary on the world…

Of course, works of art (with the important exception of music) refer to the real world—to our knowledge, to our experience, to our values. They present information and evalua­tions.  But their distinctive feature is that they give rise not to con­ceptual knowledge (which is the distinctive feature of discursive or scientific knowledge—e.g., philosophy, sociology, psychology, his­tory) but to something like an excitation, a phenomenon of commitment, judgment in a state of thralldom or captivation.

Against Interpretation, On Style; Susan Sontag, 1966

2 Comments »
Eugene Wyatt said,
2/7/2011 @ 9:01 am
Why does she except music?
lisa fox said,
5/23/2011 @ 7:58 pm
Perhaps she was thinking of physical existence? It makes no sense though because music is as physical as any thing.

Music also touches us through knowledge, experience, and values; not as a strawberry smear in a petrie dish, but more as strawberry jam on a warm corn muffin.

I think that the work aspect is also part of the distinction but I'm not quite sure how.

What do you think?
Leave a Comment
Your email address will not be posted to the public and we will not send any emails to the provided address except in direct reply to this comment.




Captcha*

This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.

Mollom CAPTCHA
Check this box to receive updates by email when
new comments are added to this item.